of Youth
  Copyright   Internet   Media
  Sex and   Censorship     Violence in   the Media

  About Us
  Contact Us
  Court and Agency Briefs
  Fact Sheets
  Policy Reports

Search FEPP


Harvard Law Review Censors Link to Nan Goldin Photograph

(June 26, 2014) - The Harvard Law Review has censored a link to an image by the prominent photographer Nan Goldin, ostensibly because of concerns about child pornography. The image, "Klara and Eddy Belly Dancing," shows two little girls cavorting, one of them nude. The link was included in an article by Marjorie Heins on censorship by private companies that offer social-media sites, web hosting, and browsing services.

Heins was invited to comment on a paper to be presented at a day-long symposium at Harvard Law School celebrating the 50th anniversary of a major Supreme Court First Amendment decision, New York Times Co. v. Sullivan. At the conference, held in February, Heins delivered her comments, which were later to be published in the Law Review's online Forum. An editor asked her to delete a reference to an incident in which a web hosting company expelled the National Coalition Against Censorship from its servers because of the presence of the Goldin photograph. The editor felt that a link to the image could be "troubling" to some readers. Heins declined to delete the reference, and reminded the editor that this was a symposium celebrating freedom of expression.

Subsequently, Heins was told by the editor-in-chief that the Review had consulted its outside counsel at the Boston law firm of Ropes and Gray, who advised against publishing the link. Despite the questionable nature of the legal advice, Heins agreed to delete the link while retaining her description of the incident. She added a note deploring the censorship of "a link to an innocent photograph by one of the country’s major artists" as "evidence of both the danger and the absurdity of confusing images of children’s bodies with child pornography."

The Heins article is available here.

"Klara and Eddy Belly Dancing" can be found here - or just by Googling the title.




The Free Expression Policy Project began in 2000 as a project of the National Coalition Against Censorship, to provide empirical research and policy development on tough censorship issues and seek free speech-friendly solutions to the concerns that drive censorship campaigns. In 2004-2007, it was part of the Brennan Center for Justice at NYU School of Law. Past funders have included the Robert Sterling Clark Foundation, the Nathan Cummings Foundation, the Rockefeller Foundation, the Educational Foundation of America, the Open Society Institute, and the Andy Warhol Foundation for the Visual Arts.

All material on this site is covered by a Creative Commons "Attribution - No Derivs - NonCommercial" license. (See You may copy it in its entirely as long as you credit the Free Expression Policy Project and provide a link to the Project's Web site. You may not edit or revise it, or copy portions, without permission (except, of course, for fair use). Please let us know if you reprint!